Pension

COFAM is seeking substantial improvements to the McGill University Pension Plan (MUPP), including the possible reconstitution of the MUPP into a single and fair plan for all employees.

In addition to negotiating its non-monetary demands, COFAM is seeking substantial improvements to the McGill University Pension Plan (MUPP)

McGill University maintains two different pension plans—Plan A and Plan B—under the MUPP, the plan that covers all of McGill’s employees except those in the Service Employees Union.

Plan A is a “hybrid” plan: it is fundamentally a defined contribution plan but with a defined benefit minimum that provides some measure of protection against market fluctuations or failure. Employees who joined the MUPP prior to 2009 are in Plan A. During a Plan-A employee’s working life, market risk is shared between the employee and McGill. Upon retirement, this risk transfers solely to the employee.

McGill’s Plan B is a defined contribution plan for employees who joined the MUPP during or after 2009. As such, it includes no minimum benefit guarantee upon retirement, and market risk is borne entirely by employees both before and during retirement.

Both plans are significantly below the standard of plans at other leading universities and law schools in Quebec and Canada.

Maintaining two distinct types of plans based on the date an employee was hired, as McGill does, is not common. In fact, in Quebec, instituting such arrangements has been illegal since 2018. Because McGill’s two-tier system pre-existed this new law, it was grandfathered in.

COFAM and the McGill University Non-Academic Certified Association (MUNACA) are both seeking substantial improvements to the MUPP, including the possibility of reconstituting the plan into a single and fair pension plan for all employees. The sub-standard quality of both Plan A and Plan B is a central bargaining issue.

More on this

McGill Pensions 101

Fact-sheet : Comparing MUPP to the U de M Pension Plan

McGill’s Two Plans for the University Pension Plan

The pension experts hired by COFAM have also discovered that McGill has helped itself to $22 million that was not theirs.

A communication from Karen Rasinger, McGill Pension Officer, dated July 2, 2025, has for the first time confirmed an ongoing misuse of MUPP member funds that has been taking place since January 1, 2014.

Three years earlier, in 2011, a Notice of Amendment was sent to Part A members describing three main changes. The most important of these changes for present purposes reads as follows: “Commencing January 1, 2014, subsequent to the results of actuarial valuations of the MUPP, in situations where additional contributions are necessary to offset funding deficiencies, Part A members will assume an equal share of the additional funding requirements.”

Although this amendment was presented to members as involving shared contributions to address “funding deficiencies” alone, it turns out that since 2014, the employer has also been deducting wages from member salaries to cover its own service costs. Communications from McGill regarding Amendment 24 have consistently and unequivocally made reference to cost-sharing to address funding deficiencies, an entirely different category than University service costs. In short, the employer has deducted contributions from Part A employees’ wages to cover service costs.

By a conservative estimate, since 2014, McGill has taken more than $20 million from Plan A members’ wages to pay 50% of service costs, which McGill alone is obligated to pay in full.

On December 17, 2025,  COFAM, in an inter-union effort supported by the Association of McGill University Research Employees (AMURE), the Association of McGill University Support Employees (AMUSE), and the McGill University Non-Academic Certified Association (MUNACA) filed a complaint against McGill University to return funds that have been misappropriated.

More on this

Fact sheet : Understanding McGill University Pension Plan (MUPP) Amendment 24

Fact sheet – Pensions for the “Golden 20”

Press Release

Legal letter : Application to expunge registration of amendment 24 (FR)

Demande d’autorisation action collective devant la Cours suprême (FR)